Alright, I'm torn and need advice. P. Manning vs NE or M. Vick vs Det in Wk 9 at QB?

I'm thinking Peyton is always a great start, but Vick vs Detroit is just compelling in so many ways...maybe I should hope that somebody offers me a trade so I don't have to decide.Alright, I'm torn and need advice. P. Manning vs NE or M. Vick vs Det in Wk 9 at QB?
If you were to ask this questions 3-4 weeks ago, I would've said Peyton Manning. Now, with ATL's revamped Offense and pocket passing presence, I would go with Michael Vick.





NE has been playing like they are back in the Super Bowl %26amp; is known for serving Peyton Manning on a Silver Plater with a side of Grandma's old fashioned buttermilk buscuits.





If Chad Pennington get ridiculous fantasy points off of the Lions, then I'm pretty sure Michael Vick can double that!Alright, I'm torn and need advice. P. Manning vs NE or M. Vick vs Det in Wk 9 at QB?
Vick should put on a show this week in Detroit, but you can't lose with manning either. Flip a coin.
my boy mike vick all the way even though peyton is a beast!
Go with either one, they are both hot!
Peyton Manning, Last week he shredded the best D in football, in Denver. I made the mistake of playing Gossman instead and I will never sit Peyten again.
Go with Vick. He is hot right now. He has 7 td's and 2 int's in the last 2 weeks. The falcons off. is going to a more passing off. so go with Vick.
P.Manning
go with Vick - Peyton's history against New England (especially in NE) is not great and the Pats' defense is playing good ball right now.
if you bench manning you are a fool. vick is good. but dont bench the best (or second best Mcnabb this season)
lol an idiot said the lions D is stronger than the pats... how freakin retarted! look at manning vs the pats in his career... except for one game he gets destroyed.. bellichick throws weird schemes at him that even he cant handle.. im sure he'll have a decent game but he wont outduel vick against the LIONS! vick is the hottest QB in the NFL right now and if they contain his legs he can now beat them with the run he has 7 tds and 2 picks in the last 2 games alone.. not to mention his rushing stats... hes been finding the open reciever more than any other by bringing in the secondary when he scrambles out the pocket and he gets one on one coverage... vick is not as much of a risk as starting manning.. vick is on a streak and its not ending this week against the lions
Peyton should never be sat!
Definently Mike Vick. Payton will not have a great day against New England, in fact I'm picking NE to upset the Colts.
I would stick with Peyton. You never know with Vick, though he's played back to back great games be weary
As a Lions Fan, go with Vick. Our team is absolutely terrible. He will own the Lions defense
vick for gods sake...rather than anybody v NE
u never sit peyton manning. why did you take him with your 1st pick? people were talking about sitting peyton last week against the broncos and look what he did to them...300+ yards and 3 TDs.





vick has shown that he can pass the last 2 weeks...but i think he's only passing more cuz the running game hasn't been great. he's bound to hit a rough game because he's just not your typical pocket passing QB. plus, i think the falcons will run the ball much better against the lions so vick won't need to pass much.
Go with Manning. Detroit's D is way stronger than the Patriots, and Vick isn't going to get nearly the traction he's used to.
Vick could have a big day early but if they get a big lead they will run the ball. I expect Manning to have some numbers vs my Pats, but some INTs too, and a sack or 12!
This is probably the only week of the year I'd play Vick over Manning.
normally i would take peyton...but not when you have vick against the lions. Go with ViCK
go with Manning he is doing good this season thats who I would pick vs NE..
I would go with Vick.
I would go with Michael Vick. Peyton Manning is a better quarterback, but look at the defenses they will be facing. The Patriots have had Peyton's number the past couple of years. On the other hand, Detroits defense won't be able to hold Michael Vick.
you would be crazy not to start vick